GLOSSARY ENTRY (DERIVED FROM QUESTION BELOW) | ||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
20:46 Jul 21, 2011 |
English language (monolingual) [PRO] Art/Literary - Philosophy / David Hume | |||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
| ||||||
| Selected response from: Charles Davis Spain Local time: 08:41 | ||||||
Grading comment
|
SUMMARY OF ALL EXPLANATIONS PROVIDED | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|
4 +6 | an idea (not experienced), formed by combining memories of separate impressions |
| ||
4 +1 | think of possibilia |
| ||
3 | mountain that appears to be golden colored |
|
mountain that appears to be golden colored Explanation: Hume is using the phrase "golden mountain" to illustrate the workings of the human mind according to his philosophical view of empiricism. I do not know if he has a particular golden mountain in mind, but there are mountains that have rock formations that appear to have a gold like color especially when the sun hits those rocks at certain times of day. -------------------------------------------------- Note added at 49 mins (2011-07-21 21:36:29 GMT) -------------------------------------------------- This example "golden mountain" was part of the philosophical discussion in Hume's time period. The following quote from the 1763 "London Magazine" does make it clear that that golden is referring to color as part of this extended philosophical discussion about the workings of the mind and imagination. "father Malebranche indeed tells us, that a man may have an idea of a golden mountain that never existed, and I can admit a man may recollect the figure of a mountain which he has formerly imagined, and remember the colour of gold which he lately had a perception of, and suppose it possible they may be connected, and call this operation of his mind, an idea if he pleases ... http://books.google.com/books?id=iboPAAAAQAAJ&pg=PA131&dq="g... -------------------------------------------------- Note added at 50 mins (2011-07-21 21:37:07 GMT) -------------------------------------------------- THE LONDON MAGAZINE OR GENTLEMEN'S MONTHLY INTELLIGENCE (Google eBook) |
| |
Login to enter a peer comment (or grade) |
golden mountain an idea (not experienced), formed by combining memories of separate impressions Explanation: This is a philosophical rather than a linguistic question. The "golden mountain" comes from David Hume's A Treatise on Human Nature (1739-40), vol. I, part 1. Hume's argument here can be summarised as follows: An experience is stronger and more vivid than the memory of that experience. Lively and forceful perceptions of the mind can be called impressions. Thoughts or ideas are less forceful. The imagination seems to be unrestrained, but actually all complex ideas are derived from simple impressions, by compounding (putting together), transposing, augmenting or diminishing mental materials derived from experience (senses or feelings). For example, the idea of a golden mountain can be traced back to our experience of "gold" and "mountain": it compounds or joins these two simple ideas, with which we are acquainted. Hume is not referring to a mountain that looks golden (perhaps because of a trick of the light), but a mountain that is actually made of gold. This is something which, necessarily, we have not experienced. We can think about it, but that thought is simply a conjunction of the ideas of gold and mountain derived from our experience. Following this, he gives a second example: a virtuous horse. Again, we cannot have experienced this; it is an idea that combines or compounds the simple ideas of virtue and horses, both of which we know separately. -------------------------------------------------- Note added at 1 hr (2011-07-21 22:10:17 GMT) -------------------------------------------------- The very interesting passage Stephanie quotes from a letter to the London Magazine illustrates the lively debate that took place on Hume's ideas in the following decades. The writer of this letter is actually saying that the idea of a golden mountain cannot be contained in the mind; the best a person can do is recollect a mountain and the colour of gold, but this is not the same thing: "We cannot properly be said to imagine what does not, or has not, really existed." |
| |
Grading comment
| ||